Whitehall High School · MSA

Internal
Playbook

2026–27 academic year. Enter your access code to open your section.

Don't have a code? Ask the President.
This is an internal document. Everything inside is club business — treat it that way.
2026–27 · Year Two

Grind the fall.
Earn the spring.

Last year proved the MSA could exist. This year it has to become something people remember. The plan is simple: fundraise hard from October through January, run real programming through Ramadan, and spend the last stretch of the year on the thing nobody at this school expects a club like ours to pull off.

Starting Balance
$150
Everything else gets earned
Meetings / Month
2–3
Up from 1 last year
Fundraisers
1 / mo
Minimum, every month we sell
The Payoff
Trip
End of year, if we earn it
The One-Sentence Strategy

Months 1–6 we build the bank and the habits. Months 7–9 we spend it on the community and on ourselves. If we fall a single month behind on fundraising, the back half shrinks — so the calendar is the plan, not a suggestion.

What's actually different this year

1. There's a finish line

Last year we ran events. This year every event feeds one visible goal, so people can see what their $3 is buying. A club with a destination fundraises differently than a club with a fundraiser.

2. Everything gets recorded

We did a lot last year and have almost nothing to show for it. No photos of full rooms, no headcounts, no proof. This year the Social Media Manager documents every single meeting. The record is the legacy.

3. Approvals happen first, not last

Nothing goes public before it's approved in writing. That rule is not bureaucracy — it is the only thing standing between this club and a shutdown. See Approval Protocol.

4. The President stops doing everything

Last year's bottleneck was one person carrying the load because delegating felt riskier than doing it alone. The fix isn't trusting more — it's writing the job down clearly enough that it can be handed off. That's what this playbook is.

This year's leadership

Edit point

Names live here and nowhere else in this playbook. Update this block and the rest of the document stays correct.

RoleWhoOwns
PresidentRehman MahmoodStrategy, approvals, meetings, recruitment, proposals, Mr. Freeman relationship
Vice President[VP name]Masjid-side events, movie nights, MALV connection, administration channel
Social Media ManagerBayanInstagram, all photo/video, the permanent record, freshman outreach support
General ManagerOpen — applications at Meeting 1Announcements, setup, sign-ups, attendance, inventory, volunteer-hour log
President in Training[Shadow name] · juniorShadows the President all year, takes over 2027–28
AdvisorMr. FreemanFinal authority above the President. Every major decision routes here first.

The non-negotiables

01
Written approval before anything goes public

Every fundraiser, event, trip, partnership and public post. Two weeks minimum. No exceptions, no "it's just a story."

02
Charity money and club money never mix

A fundraiser is labeled charity or club before it launches, and the label never changes afterward. This is the rule that protects everyone's reputation.

03
Every meeting gets documented

Photos, headcount, one-line log. Same day. No exceptions.

04
Problems come to the President before they become drama

Disagreements stay internal. Public unity always. Anyone who chooses to make it a spectacle instead is done.

05
Nobody is turned away over money

Any cost to a member has a quiet hardship path. See The Trip.

September 2026 → June 2027

The Year Map

Ten months, three phases. Phase 1 sets up. Phase 2 is the grind that pays for everything. Phase 3 is what everyone remembers.

The constraint nobody planned around last year

Ramadan falls in February 2027 (roughly Feb 8 – Mar 9, with Eid al-Fitr around March 10). That means no daytime food sales at school for a full month — our sellers are fasting and we are not running a candy table during Ramadan. The real school-selling window is October–January and then late March–May. Front-load the fall. If we treat February as a normal sales month we will be a month short in April, and April is when the trip has to be paid for.

Phase 1 · Set Up September

Week of Sept 7
Group chat temperature check

President posts the "what do you want this year" message. Two jobs: collect real ideas before the plan is locked publicly, and push everyone to pull freshmen into the WhatsApp community.

Before Meeting 1
Sit-down with Mr. Freeman

President + VP walk him through the full year plan, the trip idea, and the approval calendar. Get his read before anything is announced to members. He is the ally — he should never hear about a plan from someone else.

~Sept 17
MEETING 1 — Kickoff

Intros, new members, the year plan, the trip pitch, idea collection, General Manager applications open. Full agenda in Meetings.

Late Sept
Book the masjid social hall

VP contacts Shireen to hold an October night for Movie Night #1. Simultaneously start the administration approval for it — the event is under MSA leadership, so it needs a sign-off.

Why September is light

The President is on SAT lockdown through October 3. September is deliberately setup-only: one meeting, one sit-down, one booking. Everything heavy starts October 6. Plan around it instead of pretending it isn't there.

Phase 2 · The Grind October – March

MonthFundraiserProgrammingApproval dueTarget
OctoberMovie Night #1 (masjid) · Cake Pop Sale #12 meetings · GM selectedTrip proposal drafted$450
NovemberCake Pop Sale #22 meetings · guest speakerTrip proposal submitted$250
DecemberMovie Night #2 (winter) · Cake Pop Sale #32 meetings · community service dayBus quotes collected$550
JanuaryCake Pop Sale #4 · CHARITY DRIVE2 meetings · Ramadan prep beginsTrip decision point$300
FebruaryNo school sales — RamadanRamadan programming · community iftarIftar + Eid approvals$0
MarchMovie Night #3 (post-Eid) · Cake Pop Sale #5Eid celebration · 2 meetingsTrip permission slips out$500

Phase 3 · The Payoff April – June

April
Final push + lock the headcount

Cake Pop Sale #6, final fundraiser, trip payments collected, hardship forms processed, hour-by-hour itinerary finalized and submitted.

Late May
THE TRIP

The whole year points here. See The Trip.

Early June
Senior send-off + handoff

Recognize graduating members. President in Training formally confirmed. Playbook updated to v3.0 and signed by the outgoing President. Every login, contact and vendor handed over in writing.

Running total to beat

$450 + $250 + $550 + $300 + $0 + $500 = $2,050 by end of March, plus the $150 we started with. That is the number that makes the trip real. Everything after March is cushion.

How the money actually gets made

Fundraising Engine

Two products, two very different jobs. One makes the money. One makes us visible. Confusing which is which is how clubs end up busy and broke.

The money maker

Movie Night at the Masjid

Seasonal — fall, winter, spring. We host, families bring their kids, we make the margin on concessions. Proven format: the VP has run these for the youth group and cleared ~$300 a night.

LineDetail
FilmStreamed from a personal laptop (Prime / Apple / Disney). $0.
VenueMasjid social hall, booked through Shireen. $0.
CandyBulk, sold per piece. Cents in, quarters out.
Drinks + popcorn~$1 each. Popcorn is the highest-margin item in the building.
Upfront cost~$60 in concessions stock
Realistic net$250 – $350

Audience is kids, not students. Advertise to the families at the masjid, not to Whitehall. Different crowd, different night, no overlap with our school sales.

The visibility play

Cake Pop Sale

People buy these at Starbucks constantly. At school they sell themselves — but the margin is thin, so treat this as advertising that happens to be profitable, not as the plan.

LineNumber
Sam's Club pack of 14$18.98
Cost each$1.36
Sell price$3.00
Margin each$1.64
Revenue per pack$42.00
Profit per pack$23.02
Do the math before you fall in love with it

To fund a $1,500 bus on cake pops alone we would need to sell ~915 cake pops. That is not happening. Six sale days at a realistic 50 pops each is about $490 across the whole year. Great money. Not the plan.

Sequencing — this part matters more than the products

Start with the movie night. Not the cake pops.

We open the year with about $150. A ten-pack cake pop order is $190 — we literally cannot afford our own inventory yet. The movie night needs roughly $60 of stock and returns $300. So Movie Night #1 in October is not just a nice event, it is the working capital that makes every school sale after it possible. Run it first, then buy cake pop inventory out of the proceeds.

Trip funding calculator

Change the numbers to match real quotes as they come in. This is the live version of "can we actually do this."

Club must cover (bus + attractions + 15% contingency)
Movie night income
Cake pop income
Starting balance
Gap
Note: the per-student fee is the student's own spending money on the day. It does not fund the bus. The club funds the bus.

Rules that keep us legitimate

01
Label the fundraiser before it launches

Every fundraiser is announced as either CHARITY (100% out the door to a named, verified organization) or CLUB (funds our programming and the trip). It is declared in the first announcement and it never changes after the fact. We do not run a "50/50" and let people assume which half they funded.

02
At least one pure charity fundraiser every year

Non-negotiable, carried over from v1.0. It is a separate campaign with its own poster, its own dates and its own total announced publicly. Scheduled for January.

03
Cash or confirmed transfer, on the spot

No IOUs. No "I'll bring it tomorrow." No personal payment accounts — the club account only. This protects the seller more than it protects the club.

04
Same price for everyone

Friends, family, teachers, freshmen. $3 is $3.

05
Never sell during class

Hallways, lunch, before and after school. One incident in a classroom shuts the whole operation down.

06
The running total is public to the club

Posted after every sale day. Every member sees every dollar. Transparency is not a nicety here — it is the defense against the accusation that eventually gets made about every club that handles cash.

07
Two people count, every single time

Money is never counted alone. The General Manager and one other person count together and both initial the log. This exists to protect whoever is holding the cash.

Other fundraisers worth running if we need more

Samosa / spring roll sale

Higher margin than cake pops, strong cultural pull, and community aunties will often donate the labor. Needs a food-handling conversation with admin first.

MSA merch pre-order

Hoodies sold on a closed pre-order window. Zero inventory risk — you only order what's paid for. Doubles as branding all year.

Sponsor-a-meal (Ramadan)

Runs during the month we can't sell food at school. Community-facing, not student-facing. Pairs with the iftar.

3v3 tournament entry fees

Basketball or FIFA. Entry fee per team, gym time needs approval well in advance. Big turnout, low cost.

Donut morning

Bulk donuts before first period. Fast, simple, sells out in twenty minutes if the announcement goes out the night before.

Eid bazaar

Multi-stall event at the masjid — henna, food, small vendors, a cut of each table to the MSA. Biggest upside, most planning.

The thing the whole year is for

The Trip

An end-of-year day trip that the club pays for itself. Not a reward for leadership — a reward for everyone who showed up all year. It only happens if the money is there, and everybody knows that from day one.

The order of operations. Do not skip a step.

1. Ask the members what they want — the trip is dead on arrival if it's a leadership idea nobody else asked for.  2. Pick the destination by vote.  3. Build the full written proposal.  4. Take it to administration with the plan already finished.  5. Fundraise against a public number.  6. Go.

Destination options on the table

OptionBusCost profileRead
New York CityCharter coach required — a school bus cannot make the mileageHighestThe ambitious pick. Strongest existing connections on the ground for food, routing and logistics. Biggest approval lift and the biggest memory if it lands.
Paterson NJ — "Little Palestine"Charter, shorter runMediumReal cultural fit, halal everything, meaningfully cheaper. The smart fallback if NYC funding falls short — and a good trip in its own right, not a consolation prize.
PhiladelphiaShorter charterMedium-lowClosest big city, easiest approval. Less pull with members.
Local / in-stateSchool bus possibleLowestThe guaranteed-to-happen option. Worth keeping alive as the floor so a "no" on the big trip doesn't mean no trip at all.
Pick a primary and a fallback in the same breath

Announce it as "we're aiming for the big one, and here's the trip we run if we come up short." That way a shortfall is a downgrade instead of a failure, and nobody's disappointment turns into a story about leadership over-promising.

Draft itinerary — NYC day trip

Administration will require an hour-by-hour plan before they say yes to anything. This is the shape of it. Times are a template, not a commitment.

TimeWhereNotes
5:45 AMWhitehall — load and departAttendance taken twice: at the curb and on the bus. Chaperone assignments confirmed before wheels move.
8:30 AMArrive ManhattanGroup photo at drop-off. Ground rules restated. Buddy groups assigned — nobody moves alone all day.
9:00 AMFree museum blockChoose free / pay-what-you-wish institutions to keep per-head cost at zero.
11:30 AMWalk — High Line / ChelseaFree, contained, easy to headcount, good for photos.
1:00 PMDhuhr + group lunchHalal spot booked in advance for the group size. Prayer space arranged before the day, not found on the fly.
3:00 PMStaten Island Ferry or the piersThe ferry is free and gives the skyline and Statue views that an observation deck charges $40 a head for. This single swap is the difference between an affordable trip and an unaffordable one.
5:00 PMAsr + free time in one contained areaOne block radius, hard meet-back time, buddy groups enforced.
6:30 PMFinal headcount — departNobody boards until the count matches twice.
9:30 PMBack at WhitehallParents notified of ETA by text from the bus at the halfway point.
Nobody else will think of this, so we will

Forty Muslim students out of the district for sixteen hours means Dhuhr and Asr both fall during the trip. Prayer space gets arranged in advance and written into the itinerary as a fixed block. It makes the day work for our members, and it is also the single clearest signal to administration that this is a planned educational trip and not a bus full of teenagers wandering a city.

The $40 trap

Observation decks run roughly $36–$44 per person. For a group of forty that is $1,600 — more than the bus. If the group really wants a skyline view, ask about group rates for 15+ well in advance, or take the free ferry and spend the money on lunch instead.

What each side pays for

The club pays

  • The charter bus — the entire cost
  • Any group admission or reservation fees
  • A 15% contingency buffer
  • Any hardship-waived student fees

The student pays

  • A flat fee of roughly $50–$60
  • That covers their own food and spending money for the day
  • It is not a ticket price and it does not fund the bus
  • Comparison point: other trips at this school charge $100 because they do not fundraise at all
Hardship path — required, and handled quietly

Any student who cannot pay the fee submits a short form, signed by a parent, and the fee is covered from club funds. The form goes to the President only, it is never discussed in a meeting or a group chat, and the student's name is never attached to a waiver in any shared document.

This exists for a specific reason: a freshman who has to go home and ask their parents for $60 will simply not come, and we will never find out why. That is exactly the person this club is supposed to be for. The form is what separates genuine need from someone trying to skip the fee — the parent signature is the whole mechanism.

The proposal we hand administration

The whole approval hinges on walking in with the work already done. A club asking permission to figure it out later gets a no. A club presenting a finished plan gets negotiated with. The proposal contains, in this order:

  1. The purpose — what members get out of it, in educational and community terms, not "it would be fun"
  2. Proof of member demand — the vote results and sign-up numbers from the club itself
  3. The full hour-by-hour itinerary, including prayer blocks and meal stops
  4. Supervision plan — chaperone-to-student ratio, buddy system, headcount protocol, phone tree
  5. The complete budget — three written bus quotes, every line item, where each dollar came from
  6. The funding record — month-by-month proof we earned it ourselves and are not asking the school for money
  7. Parent permission and medical forms, ready to distribute
  8. The contingency clause — stated plainly: if we do not hit the funding target by the deadline, the trip does not happen and money is returned. Saying this first is what makes the rest of it credible.
2–3 per month, every month

Meetings

Last year's floor was one meeting a month. This year's floor is two, and the target is three. A club people forget about between meetings is a club that dies in February.

Meeting 1 — Kickoff agenda

The single most important meeting of the year. Everything downstream depends on how many people walk out of this room actually wanting to be here.

MinItemWhoWhy it's there
0–5Food out, doors open, music onGMNobody should walk into a silent room with everyone staring. The first ninety seconds decide whether a freshman comes back.
5–12Introductions — everyone, not just leadershipPresidentName, grade, one thing about you. It takes seven minutes and it is the entire reason people stay.
12–18What the MSA is and who it's forPresidentSay the quiet part out loud: this is a place to be Muslim at school without it being weird, and everyone who respects that is welcome.
18–28The year plan — the slideshowPresident + VPFundraisers, movie nights, Ramadan, Eid, and the trip at the end. Show the actual number we have to hit.
28–40Open floor — ideas and destination inputVPThis is the point of the meeting. Write every idea on the board. People fund what they helped design.
40–46General Manager role — open for applicationsPresidentExplain the job honestly, including the workload. Applications, not a popularity vote. See the role.
46–52Sign-ups — Google Form on screen, filled in the roomGM / VPForms sent to a group chat get 8 responses. Forms filled in the room get 40.
52–58Photos, group shot, next date announced out loudSMMNobody leaves without knowing the next date, and the room gets documented.

Standard meeting format

Before

  • Announcement 48h ahead + reminder morning-of
  • Room confirmed with the Advisor
  • Food and setup done before anyone arrives
  • SMM posts a story that morning

During

  • Attendance taken — actual count, written down
  • Money update: the running total, every time
  • One clear ask before anyone leaves
  • Photos and video captured

After

  • One-line log to the record, same day
  • Story posted same day
  • Next date announced in the group chat
  • Leadership debrief: what worked, what didn't
The rule that makes meetings feel worth attending

Every meeting ends with one specific thing to do and one date to remember. Not five. If a member leaves a meeting unable to say what the club is doing next, the meeting failed regardless of how well it went in the room.

Announcement format

Same format every time, so members recognize an official MSA announcement at a glance and actually read it.

Sept 15
📢 MSA Kickoff Meeting — Year One of Something Big

First meeting of the year and we're doing things differently. Come find out what we're building.

📅 Date: Thursday, Sept 17
Time: 3:00 – 4:00 PM
📍 Location: Mr. Freeman's room

Food will be there. Bring a friend, bring a freshman. See you there 🙌

Why this works: date stamp at the top so people know it's current · bold headline that survives a busy chat · a hook line that gives a reason to keep reading · the three things people always forget in their own block · a closing push that's warm rather than nagging.

The most important thing in this document

Bringing People In

Every year this club is one bad recruiting season away from not existing. And the mechanism that actually works is not a poster.

The reason this section exists

The current President is only in this club because a president three years ago walked up to him in a bathroom and asked if he was Muslim, then told him to come to a meeting because it was a good place to be. That was it. That was the whole recruitment strategy and it changed the next four years of his life.

No flyer does that. No Instagram post does that. A person walking up to another person and inviting them by name does that. Everything below is built around making that happen on purpose instead of by luck.

The rule

THE ONE RULE
Every leader personally invites five underclassmen, face to face, by the second meeting

Not a group chat link. Not a story repost. Walk up, say their name, tell them what the club is, tell them when it meets, and tell them you'll look for them there. Then actually look for them there.

How the first month runs

Step 1
Visibility before invitation

Freshmen cannot join a club they have never heard of. Before we ask anyone to come, they need to have seen the name — a lunch table, morning announcements, posters up where underclassmen actually walk.

Step 2
The personal invite — the part that works

Each leader takes their five. The Social Media Manager knows the incoming class best and should be leaned on heavily here. The President owns overall recruiting so nobody's schedule becomes the bottleneck.

Step 3
Bring-a-friend incentive, first two meetings only

A small prize for whoever brings the most underclassmen. Run it for two meetings and then stop — if it runs all year it turns membership into a competition instead of a community, and the freshmen can feel the difference.

Step 4
The group chat push

A single message asking everyone to add the freshmen they know. This is the amplifier, never the strategy.

Step 5
Make the first meeting survivable for a nervous 14-year-old

Someone greets them at the door by name. They are not left standing alone. Introductions go around the whole room so they hear other people's names too. Food is out before they walk in.

Step 6
The follow-up nobody does

Within 48 hours, whoever invited them messages them personally: good having you there, next one is on the 30th. One message. This is the single highest-return thing in this entire playbook and it takes ninety seconds.

The recruiting angle we are underusing

Volunteer hours

Service hours are a graduation requirement, every underclassman needs them, and most of them have no idea where to get them. The MSA can hand out documented hours — movie night setup and concessions, masjid events, Ramadan iftar service, community food drives, MALV events.

That turns "come to our club" into "come to our club and solve a problem you already have." The General Manager keeps a signed hour log for every member. It costs us nothing, it makes joining concretely valuable, and it gives the club a legitimate service record to point at when we ask administration for something big.

What we are actually building

The measure of this year is not the fundraising total and it is not the trip. It is whether a freshman who walked in nervous in September is still here in June, and whether they would walk up to someone else next year and do what was done for them.

Everyone graduates. What we build now decides whether this club exists in five years or goes back to being a name on a list with nothing behind it.

February – March 2027

Ramadan & Eid

The month the club matters most, and the month our normal fundraising model stops working. Both facts need planning in December, not February.

Dates — confirm locally, plan around them now

Ramadan 2027 begins around February 8 and ends around March 9, with Eid al-Fitr around March 10. Exact dates depend on the moonsighting our community follows — confirm with the masjid in December. Everything in the year map assumes this window.

What changes during Ramadan

Stops

  • All daytime food sales at school. Our sellers are fasting and we are not running a candy table during Ramadan.
  • After-school meetings that run late — people need to get home for iftar.
  • Anything that competes with taraweeh in the evening.

Starts

  • Community-facing fundraising: sponsor-a-meal, donation drives.
  • Short meetings during the school day instead of after it.
  • Weekly programming that gives people a reason to be together during the month.

Week-by-week plan

WeekProgramOwnerPrep due
Prep · JanRamadan kickoff meeting. Prayer room arrangements confirmed with administration. Iftar date locked with the masjid.President + VPEarly January
Week 1Welcome-the-month gathering. Set the tone, announce the schedule for the whole month at once.PresidentLate January
Week 2Sponsor-a-meal drive launches. Community-facing, not student-facing.GMLate January
Week 3Community iftar — the flagship event. Families invited, open to the wider school community.VP (lead) + PresidentApproval by early January
Week 4Last-ten-nights programming, coordinated with the masjid rather than competing with it.VPFebruary
EidEid celebration — food, decorations, members plus guests. The best-attended event of the year if it's done right.President + GMApproval by February
Two things to handle in advance that always get handled late

Prayer space during the school day. Ramadan makes this visible in a way it isn't the rest of the year. Ask administration in January, in writing, politely, with a specific room and a specific window. Asking early and quietly gets a yes far more often than asking in the middle of the month when it's already a problem.

The MALV connection. The masjid has the space, the audience, the volunteers and the credibility. The VP already has that relationship — it is the single biggest force multiplier the club has, and it should be used deliberately rather than only when something needs a venue.

Four leadership roles + the shadow

The Roles

Every responsibility in this club has a name attached to it. That is the entire reason things stop falling through the cracks. Open your role, read all of it, and know what the others own too.

Print any role as a PDF

Open a role page and print it (⌘P / Ctrl+P, then Save as PDF). The page is formatted to print clean on its own — navigation and interface strip out automatically. That's how you hand someone their role on paper.

Role 01

President

You make the plans. You get them approved. You run the meetings. You hold everyone accountable, including yourself. If something happens in this club it's because you made it happen, and if something fails it's because you didn't catch it in time.

Core responsibilities

  • Plan the entire year — meetings, fundraisers, programming, the trip.
  • Run every leadership and general meeting. Focused, on time, and worth attending.
  • Get written approval from the Advisor and administration before anything starts. Two weeks minimum.
  • Approve every public-facing post, poster and announcement before it goes live.
  • Own recruitment. The freshman intake is the President's responsibility and cannot be delegated away.
  • Hold the running money total and publish it to the club after every sale.
  • Build and protect the relationship with the Advisor. He is the reason this club is allowed to exist.
  • Train the President in Training all year. Not at the end — all year.
  • Make sure every single member gets talked to, not just the people you already know.

Weekly rhythm

Every week

  • Check in with the Advisor
  • Post an update to the group chat
  • Reply to leadership within 24 hours
  • Review anything queued to go public

Every month

  • 2–3 meetings held
  • At least one fundraiser executed
  • Money total published
  • Next month's approvals submitted
The failure mode to actively fight this year

Last year the President did almost everything alone, because handing work off felt riskier than absorbing it. The result was a year that worked and a President who was fried, with no system anyone else could pick up.

The fix is not "trust people more." The fix is that a job written down clearly enough can be handed to someone who has never done it. That is what this playbook is for. When you catch yourself doing someone else's job, the correct response is to write their job down better — not to keep doing it.

What you do not do

  • Commit the club to anything without the Advisor's approval.
  • Let a public post go out unreviewed, including a story.
  • Handle club cash alone. Two people count, always.
  • Let a month pass without a meeting.
  • Discuss personnel decisions in the group chat. Ever.

Removal & authority

The President can be removed only by the Advisor, and only for consistent failure to meet expectations, loss of trust, or a Code of Conduct violation. No member, no VP, no coalition can remove the President. The trade is that the Advisor is a real check — stay in honest communication with him, follow the approval process, and there is never cause.

Succession — the Shadow Program

There is no election for President. The role holds the most authority, makes every major decision, and is the only position that reports to the Advisor — it does not go to whoever is most popular, it goes to whoever has been trained. The current President and the Advisor select the President in Training together, before senior year begins.

By June that person must be able to run a meeting, get an approval, lead a fundraiser, handle a conflict and talk to the Advisor without help. If they can't, the pick was wrong and it has to be addressed before handoff rather than discovered after it. See President in Training.

Role 02

Vice President

One rank below the President and the club's second decision-maker. When the President isn't there, you don't hold things together — you run them, fully. This year the VP also owns two things the President genuinely cannot do alone.

What this VP owns outright

The masjid side

Movie nights, hall booking, community events, the iftar. The President has not run masjid-side events before and is not pretending otherwise — the VP leads these, sets the plan, and tells the President what she needs from him. That is a real handoff, not a formality.

The administration channel

The VP has the stronger existing relationship with the administrator who signs off on events, built through another club presidency. She leads that conversation from now on. The President attends every one of those conversations — not to take over, but so nothing gets agreed to in one room and remembered differently in another.

The MALV connection

The VP is the club's link to the wider Muslim community. Venue access, volunteers, audiences, credibility with families. This is the club's biggest force multiplier and it should be used on purpose throughout the year, not only when an event needs a room.

Core responsibilities

  • Run meetings when the President is absent — fully, not partially.
  • Lead all masjid-based events end to end: booking, plan, setup, concessions, close-out.
  • Lead the administration approval conversations, with the President present.
  • Be the trusted contact for members who have a question or a problem, and escalate what you can't resolve.
  • Hold authority in the group chat — enforce the rules and back the President publicly.
  • Create Google Forms for sign-ups and feedback.
  • Make posters and slides when you have the time and want to; hand them to the President when you don't.
  • Help capture content at events so the record doesn't depend on one person.

Schedule reality — written down so it stops being a problem

The VP is not in the high school building most mornings

She's at Cookstown and the elementary schools until roughly 11:00–11:30 AM on most days. That is a fixed commitment, not a scheduling preference.

What that means concretely: the VP does not do morning sales, morning announcements, or freshman recruiting in the hallways. Those belong to the President, the GM and the SMM. The VP's contribution lands in the afternoons, the evenings and the masjid — which is where the highest-value work of this year actually is.

This is in the playbook on purpose. A constraint that everyone knows about is a plan. A constraint nobody mentioned is a resentment.

The working agreement between President and VP

01
Say what you can't do, up front

Both directions. Nobody is annoyed by a limit that was stated early. Everyone is annoyed by one discovered the day of the event.

02
Neither of us talks to administration about a plan alone

Both in the room for anything that gets agreed to. Prevents the exact miscommunication that causes an "approved" thing to turn out not to be.

03
Check in once a week, minimum, even in a quiet week

The weeks that don't feel like they need a check-in are the ones where things drift.

04
Disagree privately, back each other publicly

Always. In the group chat, in a meeting, in front of members. The disagreement gets settled between you two.

05
Nobody takes on a task they don't actually have time for

Declining a task in advance is a contribution. Accepting one and dropping it is the thing that costs the club a month.

Removal & authority

The VP serves at the President's discretion and can be removed for consistent failure to meet expectations — missed meetings, slow communication, no follow-through. The decision is the President's, with the Advisor informed. It's written plainly rather than left implied: show up, communicate, do the job, and the role is yours.

Role 03

Social Media Manager

You are the only public face this club has, and this year you are also something bigger than that: you are the reason next year's MSA will be able to see what this year looked like.

Why this role got promoted this year

Last year the club did real things — real events, full rooms, money raised, people who genuinely enjoyed themselves. And there is almost no record that any of it happened. You can't go back and see a meeting. You can't see how many people came. You can't show a freshman, or an administrator, or next year's president what it looked like.

That is the gap this role closes. Posting is half the job. The other half is building a permanent archive of the year — and that half is the one that outlives all of us.

The two jobs

Job 1 — The feed

Instagram is the club's public presence. It's how students who aren't in the club find out we exist, how families see what we do, and how the school sees we're serious. It should look like a real organization runs it, because one does.

Job 2 — The archive

Every meeting and event gets photographed, filmed and filed — whether or not any of it gets posted. Raw footage goes into a shared drive folder by date. This is the club's memory and it is not optional.

Core responsibilities

  • Post before every meeting — a reminder story or post the day before and the morning of.
  • Post during every meeting — live stories from the room. This is what makes people who skipped it show up next time.
  • Post after every meeting — a recap with photos of actual people, same day.
  • Film and photograph everything. Meetings, fundraisers, movie nights, setup, the boring parts. You cannot edit footage you didn't shoot.
  • Take photos of people, not just rooms and posters. Faces are what makes an account feel like a community instead of a bulletin board.
  • Edit — reels, recap videos, and yes, the funny ones. Humor is what actually gets people to a meeting; a formal announcement graphic does not.
  • Design posters for every event, or hand it to the President who can turn one around in ten minutes with AI. Either is fine. A late poster is not.
  • Answer DMs and comments within 24 hours, professionally.
  • File the raw footage in the shared folder, dated, after every event.
  • Protect the account credentials. Shared with the President only.

Content system — so it's never a blank page

WhenWhat goes outFormat
2 days before a meetingAnnouncement post — date, time, room, one reason to comePoster or graphic
Morning ofReminderStory
DuringLive shots of the room, the food, people talkingStories, 3–5 of them
Same dayRecap with the best photosCarousel post
Weekly, any weekAyah or hadith of the weekSimple graphic
MonthlyMember spotlight — one member, their story, why they joinedPost
Fundraiser weeksRunning total updates and the countdown to the goalStory series
Before big eventsThe funny one — a bit, a skit, something that actually gets sharedReel
The hard rule — there is exactly one and it is absolute

Every post, story, reel, caption and reply is approved by the President before it goes live. No exceptions. Not "it was just a story." Not "I thought it was fine."

This is not about trust and it is not about creative control. Everything published under this name represents every Muslim student in the building, the Advisor, and the school. The club has already come close to being shut down once over a single public post, and the President was the one who had to sit in that room and answer for it. One careless post can end the club for everyone. Posting without approval is grounds for immediate removal from the role.

Anything political, sensitive, or about world events

Goes to the President before it is designed, not after. The answer is often yes with a rewrite. The answer is never "post it and see." If you are unsure whether something counts, it counts — ask.

Equipment & tools

  • Proper recording and editing equipment is being provided by the President — ask for what you actually need rather than working around a phone.
  • Canva or Canva AI for posters. The President can generate design work on request in about ten minutes if you're short on time.
  • A shared drive folder for raw footage, organized by date.
  • Instagram credentials, shared with the President only.

Success and failure

Success

Students who never attend a meeting still know what the MSA is doing. Every event has a post before, stories during and a recap after. By June there's a full year of footage anyone can scroll back through. A freshman can see what they're joining before they walk in.

Failure

The page goes quiet for weeks. Events happen with no photos. Posters land the day of. DMs sit unanswered. And the worst one: something goes up without approval.

Role 04 · Currently open

General Manager

The operator. If the VP is the President's right hand for leadership, the General Manager is the President's right hand for everything actually getting done. This is the least glamorous role in the club and the one that decides whether a year works.

Core responsibilities

  • Announcements. Post every official announcement in the group chat, in the standard format, on time. At least one a week during active fundraiser and event windows.
  • Talk to members. Answer questions, gauge interest, collect opinions, and tell the President what people are actually saying — not what they say in a meeting.
  • Setup and teardown. Food, drinks, tables, chairs. Done before anyone arrives, cleared after everyone leaves.
  • Sign-ups. Chase people until the Google Form is actually filled. A form with 8 responses when 40 said they were coming is a General Manager problem.
  • Attendance. A real headcount at every meeting and event, written down. This number is how we prove the club is growing.
  • Supplies. Bulk runs, inventory of boxes, decorations and banners, and never letting stock run out mid-sale.
  • The money log. Count every sale with one other person present. Both initial it. Hand the total to the President the same day.
  • The volunteer hour log. Track and sign off service hours for every member who works an event. See below — this one matters more than it sounds.
  • Capture footage. Record meetings and events and hand the raw files to the Social Media Manager.
  • Be the second set of hands wherever the President or VP needs one.
The part of this job that gives it real weight

The General Manager owns the volunteer hour log. Service hours are a graduation requirement and most underclassmen have no idea where to get them. Because you keep a signed, dated record of who worked which event, joining this club becomes concretely worth something to every member — and the club gets a documented service record to point at when it asks the school for something big.

You are not doing paperwork. You are running the single strongest reason an underclassman has to keep showing up.

Weekly rhythm

  • At least one announcement in the group chat during active weeks.
  • Check in with the President about what the week needs.
  • Reply to the President within 24 hours.
  • Attend every leadership meeting.

How this role gets filled

Applications, announced at a meeting. Not a group chat thread, not a popularity vote.

The role is opened at Meeting 1, in the room. The President explains the job honestly — including the workload — and anyone interested applies. Applications are reviewed by the President and VP together, and the decision is made on readiness, not friendship.

It is not put up for discussion in the group chat. That turns a hiring decision into a public referendum and generates exactly the kind of drama that cost the club a good ending last year.

What we're actually looking for

  • Organized. Genuinely, provably — the kind of person whose work gets handed in on time without being chased.
  • Responsible with money and with other people's time.
  • Available during the school day, particularly in the mornings, since that's when sales and setup happen.
  • Comfortable talking to people they don't already know.
  • Not already overcommitted to three other clubs. This role needs real hours.

What applicants are told

"This is the role that makes everything else work. If you want to be part of what this club becomes this year, and you're willing to do real work that mostly happens behind the scenes, apply. If you want a title for a college application, don't."

Success and failure

Success

Announcements go out on time every time. Events are set up before anyone arrives. Forms get filled. Supplies never run out. The money log is clean. The President never has to ask twice.

Failure

Announcements go out late or not at all. Events start late because nothing was ready. Forms are empty. The President ends up doing your job, which is exactly the failure mode this whole year is designed to prevent.

Role 05

President in Training

You are not an assistant and you are not an intern. You are next year's President, learning the job in real time for a full year before you inherit it, so that you start from where this year ended instead of from zero.

Why this role exists at all

Most school clubs reset every time a senior graduates. Everything the last leader learned walks out the door with them and the next person spends a year rediscovering it. This club is deliberately built not to do that.

What the year looks like

  • Sit in on every leadership meeting from September.
  • Be in the room for Advisor and administration conversations where it's appropriate.
  • Help plan meetings, fundraisers and events — not just attend them.
  • Get handed real things to run, on purpose, while there's still someone to catch it.
  • Watch how conflict and approvals actually get handled, including the parts that go badly.
  • Take over pieces of meetings so that running one stops being intimidating before it's your job.

The bar by June

You should be able to do all of these without help: run a full meeting, get an event approved through the Advisor and administration, lead a fundraiser end to end, handle a conflict between members, talk to the Advisor as an equal, and represent the club to people outside it.

If you can't do all of that by graduation, the pick was wrong — and that gets addressed before the handoff, honestly, rather than discovered in October when it's your problem alone.

The handoff, in writing

Before the outgoing President leaves, all of this transfers on paper: every login, the Advisor and administration contacts, vendor and masjid contacts, the money records, the archive folder, the approval history, and this playbook updated to the next version with the year's learnings written into it.

Standing offer from the founder of this system

The person who built this doesn't disappear at graduation. Overwhelmed, stuck, facing a hard call, dealing with a conflict in leadership — reach out. Asking is always better than guessing. This club matters too much to let one bad month break it.

Everyone

Members

Leadership exists to serve the membership, not the other way around. Every event, every fundraiser and every program exists because members show up.

Who can join

Any student at Whitehall who joins, follows the rules and participates. You do not have to be Muslim to be here. You have to respect the community.

What's expected

  • Show up to what you commit to, or say in advance that you can't. Either is fine. Silence isn't.
  • Respect every other member, full stop.
  • Follow the group chat rules.
  • Support fundraisers where you can — sell, buy, or share.
  • Bring ideas. Good ones get used, and the people who bring them get asked to help run them.
  • Represent the club decently outside of meetings.

What you're owed

  • A voice. Any idea or concern goes to the VP, or straight to the President if it involves the VP.
  • A real answer when you raise something. Not a brush-off.
  • Full transparency on money. The running total is published to the whole club.
  • Documented volunteer hours for every event you work.
  • A fair shot at leadership if you show up and contribute.
  • The freedom to leave whenever you want, no questions and no hard feelings.
  • A place where being Muslim at school isn't something you have to explain or downplay.

Getting into leadership

Roles aren't handed out, they're earned, and the path is not a secret: show up consistently, volunteer for the unglamorous tasks, build trust with the people currently doing the job, and say out loud that you're interested. That's it. That's the whole path.

Structure

Chain of Command

Every responsibility has a name attached to it, and every decision has a path. This isn't hierarchy for its own sake — it's what stops things from falling through the cracks and stops disagreements from becoming factions.

ADVISOR
Mr. Freeman · final authority
PRESIDENT
reports only to the Advisor
VICE PRESIDENT
acting President when needed
GENERAL MANAGER
operations
SOCIAL MEDIA MGR
public face + record
MEMBERS
the club

The President in Training sits alongside the President all year, observing and practicing, outside the reporting line.

The rules

RULE 1
The President holds final authority inside the club

Plans, events, fundraisers, strategy, public decisions. Nobody — VP, GM or SMM — commits the club to anything without the President's approval. Any role created in the future still sits under the President.

RULE 2
Decisions flow down, never sideways

The President directs the VP, GM and SMM. The VP directs members. The GM directs anyone helping with logistics. The SMM directs anyone helping with content.

RULE 3
Issues escalate up, never skipping a level

Members raise things with the VP first. If unresolved, the VP takes it to the President. A member who skips straight to the President gets redirected — unless the issue involves the VP, in which case it goes directly to the President.

RULE 4
Disputes between leadership are settled by the President

Final inside the club. The only appeal above the President is the Advisor.

RULE 5
The chain doesn't break when someone's absent

President unavailable, the VP is Acting President for that day or event. Both unavailable, the GM handles operational decisions only — anything major waits.

RULE 6
Communication is the job, not a courtesy

Leadership replies to the President within 24 hours and attends scheduled leadership meetings unless excused in advance. Going quiet is the fastest way to lose a role here.

The rule that keeps the club alive

Approval Protocol

If you only read one section of this playbook, read this one. Every other page describes what we want to do. This page describes the only way any of it is allowed to happen.

The golden rule

Nothing goes public before it's approved in writing. Every fundraiser, every event, every partnership, every trip, every public-facing post. Two weeks minimum for anything involving money, school facilities, or an outside organization.

Why this is stricter than it needs to be

A student club that represents a religious community operates with less margin for error than most clubs at this school. A single public post that lands wrong — even one that would be unremarkable coming from anyone else — can turn into a meeting where the club's continued existence is genuinely on the table. That has already happened here once, and the President was the one who had to sit in that room, take responsibility, and put in writing how it wouldn't happen again.

The lesson isn't to be quiet or to be afraid. It's this: get approval early, in writing, for everything, so that the answer is already settled before anyone has to ask a question about it. Approval obtained in advance is protection. Approval sought after the fact is damage control.

Who to talk to

WhoFor whatWho leads it
The Advisor (Mr. Freeman)Every major decision, mentorship, conflicts, questions. The first call for anything.President
School administrationEvent and fundraiser approval, room and facility reservations, school-wide announcements, trips.VP leads, President attends
Main officePaper forms, official submissions, scheduling.GM
The masjid (via Shireen)Social hall booking, community event coordination.VP

The approval chain

  1. Bring it to the Advisor first. Talk it all the way through before it goes anywhere else. He should never hear about an MSA plan from somebody other than us.
  2. Take it to administration in writing, with the plan already built — not as an idea to be figured out later.
  3. Complete any required paper forms at the main office.
  4. Submit them and follow up by email so there's a record of the submission.
  5. Wait for written confirmation. Verbal is not confirmation. "Sounds good" is not confirmation.
  6. Only then announce, post, sell, or book anything.

The rules on top of the chain

01
Both President and VP in every administration conversation

Neither goes alone. It prevents something being agreed in one room and remembered differently in another, and it means the club always has two people who heard the same answer.

02
Get the approval calendar done early, not per-event

Submit the year's plan in blocks rather than scrambling two weeks before each thing. It's less work overall and it makes the club look like it's run by people who plan.

03
Anything political or tied to world events goes to the President before it's made

Not after it's designed, not once it's scheduled. Before. The answer is often yes with a rewrite — but that conversation happens first.

04
Never go around administration

Not once, not for something small. The club's ability to do anything ambitious rests entirely on being the club that does things the right way.

05
A denial is usually a missing detail, not a no

Ask what would change the answer, fix it, resubmit. Most denials are about an unanswered logistics question.

The upside nobody mentions

A club with a spotless approval record gets to ask for bigger things. Every clean, well-documented, on-time event this year is what makes an out-of-state trip a reasonable ask in the spring instead of an outrageous one. The paperwork is the strategy.

Standards

Conduct & Group Chat

The group chat is the club's nervous system. It's also where every problem this club has ever had started. Both things are true and the rules below account for both.

Code of conduct — all members

  • Be on time to what you commit to.
  • Respond within 24 hours when you're tagged.
  • Represent the club respectfully on and off school grounds.
  • Disagreements stay internal. Public unity, always.
  • Respect every member regardless of background, gender or how well you know them.
What this club is actually for

This is supposed to be a place where Muslim students at this school have a community — something a lot of people who came before us never got to have. That is the entire point, and it is bigger than anyone's ego about how something got run.

Anyone is welcome to disagree with a decision, and there's a channel for it. Nobody is welcome to turn a disagreement into a campaign. Bring it to the President. That's not a formality — it's a genuine open door, and it's the only one.

Group chat rules — pinned

  1. Respect every member. No personal attacks, slurs, harassment or targeting.
  2. Keep it relevant to the MSA. This isn't a meme dump.
  3. No promoting personal businesses, side hustles or unrelated events without approval.
  4. No inappropriate content — nothing you wouldn't say in front of the Advisor.
  5. Stay civil. Disagreement is fine. Insults and drama aren't.
  6. No spam, mass tagging or chain forwards.
  7. Everything posted here represents the club. Act accordingly.

Who manages the chat

  • President — primary admin, final authority.
  • Vice President — admin, enforces rules and backs the President.
  • General Manager — admin, posts announcements and adds members.
  • Social Media Manager — admin only with President approval.
  • Only the President, VP or GM add new members. New members get welcomed and pointed at the pinned rules.

Penalty ladder

OffensePenaltyNotes
FirstWarning, removal up to 24 hoursRe-added with a reminder of the rules.
SecondRemoval up to 72 hoursMember acknowledges the rules in writing before re-entry.
ThirdRemoval up to 2 weeksConversation with the President required before re-entry.
Beyond thirdIndefinite removalDecided by President and Advisor together.
Severe, any timeImmediate removal pending Advisor reviewHarassment, hate speech, or anything that endangers another member.

Penalties are applied by the President with the VP's input, and briefly documented so future incidents have context. Anything that happens in the chat can be reported at any time — to the VP first, or straight to the President if it involves the VP. Every report is taken seriously.

On drama, stated plainly

Last year ended worse than it should have because of conflict that could have been raised directly and wasn't. That is not happening again. Anyone who chooses to attack the leadership publicly or work members against the club instead of bringing the problem to the President is removed, with the Advisor informed.

The door for honest disagreement is genuinely open, and it will stay open. The door for making a spectacle out of it is closed.

The fix for last year's biggest gap

The Record

We did a whole year of real work and kept almost no proof of it. That ends here. Every meeting and every event leaves a trace, and the traces are what the next president inherits.

What gets logged, every time

FieldWhoWhen
Date and type of eventGMSame day
Headcount — the real numberGMDuring
Money in / money outGM + one witnessSame day
Photos and video, filed by dateSMMSame day
What worked, what didn't — one linePresidentSame day
Volunteer hours worked, by memberGMSame day
Why the headcount is on this list

It's the only hard number that proves the club is growing. It's what you show administration when you ask for something big, it's what you show a potential guest speaker, and it's what tells next year's president whether a given event is worth repeating. "It felt like a good turnout" is worth nothing in April.

Where it lives

  • This playbook — the plans, the roles, the rules. Updated as the year goes and versioned at handoff.
  • Shared drive folder — raw photos and video by date, posters, forms, approval emails.
  • Money log — every sale, two initials, running total.
  • Hour log — every member, every event worked, signed.
  • Instagram — the public half of the record.

Version history

VersionYearAuthorChanges
1.02025–26Rehman MahmoodInitial manual established — roles, chain of command, fundraising playbook.
2.02026–27Rehman MahmoodMoved from document to living playbook. Added the year map, the trip, the funding model, Ramadan planning, the volunteer-hour system, the recruiting method, the record, and rewrote every role around this year's actual team.
3.02027–28Next president signs here.

Every president who inherits this is expected to update it with what they learned, add what's missing, and sign their changes. That's how it stays alive instead of becoming a document nobody opens.

Pass it down. Keep it alive. Leave it stronger.

President & Vice President only

War Room

The working document between the two people running this club. Everything here came out of the planning conversations. It gets updated as the year moves.

Agreed so far

TopicWhere we landed
Fundraiser cadenceSeasonal movie nights at the masjid plus a school sale at least once a month. Movie nights are the money; school sales are the visibility.
First fundraiserFall movie night in October. Runs first because it needs almost no capital and generates the working capital for everything after it.
School productCake pops at $3. Both sides sold on it. Margin is understood to be thin.
Year shapeGrind the first six months, spend the last three. Agreed by both.
End-of-year tripYes in principle. Destination decided by member vote, not by leadership. NYC is the ambitious target; Paterson NJ is the realistic fallback; local is the floor.
Trip cost splitClub funds the bus entirely. Students pay ~$50–60 for their own food and spending. Hardship path required.
BroadwayOff the table. ~$100 a ticket, eats the whole budget, takes half the day.
Administration channelVP leads. President attends every conversation. Both agreed.
Masjid-side eventsVP leads and sets the plan. President supports and does what she asks.
Freshman recruitingPresident owns it. VP's morning schedule makes it impossible for her; SMM assists.
Other schools' MSAsNot this year. We run our own events at our own standard. Revisit only if a specific opportunity is clearly worth it.
Posters and slidesVP makes them when she has the time and wants to. President generates them in minutes when she doesn't. No obligation either way.
General ManagerOpen. Filled by application at Meeting 1, reviewed by President and VP together. Never discussed in the group chat.
Social mediaCovered. SMM has the role, equipment being provided, full brief written.
Meeting cadence2–3 per month, up from one.
SeptemberSetup only. President on SAT lockdown until October 3, stated up front so nobody plans around a person who isn't available.

The working agreement

01
State limits up front, both directions

Neither of us is annoyed by a constraint we heard about in advance. Both of us are annoyed by one discovered the day of.

02
Neither of us talks to administration about a plan alone

Both in the room for anything that gets agreed to.

03
Weekly check-in, even in quiet weeks

Especially in quiet weeks.

04
Disagree privately, back each other publicly

Every time, without exception.

05
Consistency is the whole plan

One month behind on fundraising compounds into a trip that doesn't happen. If a month is going to slip, we say so while there's still time to fix it, not after.

Immediate to-do

  • Post the "what do you want this year" message in the group chat, with a freshman push attached
  • Confirm the Meeting 1 date and room with Mr. Freeman
  • President + VP sit-down with Mr. Freeman on the full year plan, before Meeting 1
  • VP contacts Shireen to hold an October night for Movie Night #1
  • Start the approval paperwork for the October movie night
  • Build the Meeting 1 slideshow
  • Write the General Manager application form
  • Confirm the SMM equipment list and order what's missing
  • Get three written charter bus quotes so the trip number stops being a guess
  • Decide the trip destination shortlist to put to a member vote
  • Confirm exact Ramadan dates with the masjid
Leadership

Open Decisions

Things not yet settled. Each one has an owner and a point by which it has to be answered, so nothing sits in limbo until it becomes urgent.

QuestionOwnerNeeded byNotes
Trip destinationMembers, by voteMeeting 2Leadership presents the shortlist with real costs. Members choose. This is what makes the fundraising theirs rather than ours.
Actual bus costPresidentNovemberThree written quotes. Every number in the plan is an estimate until this exists.
Per-student fee — $50 or $60President + VPJanuaryDepends on how fundraising actually goes. Lower is better; the hardship path exists either way.
Who fills General ManagerPresident + VPEnd of OctoberBy application, reviewed together, decided on readiness. Not in the group chat.
Bring-a-freshman prize — what is itPresidentMeeting 1Small and cheap. Two meetings only, then it stops.
Charity for the January drivePresident + AdvisorDecemberVerified organization, clean reputation, no political exposure. Approved with the Advisor before it's named publicly.
Exact Ramadan datesVPDecemberConfirm with the masjid. The entire spring calendar depends on it.
Prayer space during RamadanVP + PresidentJanuaryAsk early, in writing, with a specific room and window.
Guest speaker for the yearVPOctoberMALV connection is the route. Required by the manual, and it's the easiest big win available.
Volunteer hour approvalPresidentOctoberConfirm with the school which MSA activities count toward the service requirement, and get it in writing.
Merch — yes or no this yearPresidentJanuaryOnly if the fall fundraising is ahead of schedule. Pre-order model, no inventory risk.
How to use this page

Every leadership meeting opens by looking at this table. Anything past its date gets decided in the room or reassigned. A decision that stays open for two months isn't a decision, it's an avoidance.